top of page

November Water News

CWC
31 minutes ago
8 min read

Data Centers and Florida’s Water: What to Know


Data centers are quickly becoming one of Florida’s (and the rest of the country’s) big water dilemmas. These facilities house the computers necessary for cloud storage and streaming of artificial intelligence. The computers run hot around the clock. Keeping them cool takes a lot of electricity and a lot of water.


How much? A September 2026 Florida TaxWatch report modeled one large “hyperscale” AI data center (500 megawatts) and estimated it would use more than 10,600 megawatt-hours of electricity a day (roughly what a quarter-million Florida homes use) and evaporate more than 2.2 million gallons of water a day in cooling. That water isn’t borrowed and returned to the aquifer.


For perspective, Indian River County’s entire utility system is permitted to pump about 16.2 million gallons a day. A single facility like the one modeled would consume roughly one-seventh of that amount.


Not every data center is that large, and the technology is changing. Closed-loop systems recirculate water, and some facilities can cool with reclaimed wastewater instead of drinking water. There’s a trade-off, though: cooling methods that use less water generally use more electricity, and vice versa. The right answer depends on the site.


Why should we care if no one has proposed a data center here? Because our drinking water comes from the Upper Floridan aquifer, the same aquifer system beneath North Florida’s springs and most of the state. Proposals have surfaced in Jackson County in the Panhandle, in Citrus County near the Crystal River springs, and in Indiantown just down the coast in Martin County. Several counties have paused applications while they write standards, and the Southwest Florida Water Management District now requires its full governing board to approve any data center water permit. The aquifer doesn’t follow county lines, and how the state handles big new water demands can have a far-reaching impact.


Our own supply is already tight. The county’s water use permit runs through October 2031, but  projections show demand passing the permitted amount, before the permit even expires. The county is now undertaking a study of the Hobart Well Field, using the water management district’s regional groundwater model rather than an updated local study of the aquifer under our feet.


Florida took a first step by passing The Florida Hyperscale Data Center Act (SB 484) which:

  • bars water managers from issuing permits that would harm area water resources

  • calls for reclaimed water where feasible

  • requires a hearing before major permits are approved.

  • Local governments also keep the power to say no or set stricter standards.

 What’s still missing is a statewide approach. Water use permits are handled by five separate water management districts, each with its own process, and the state’s study of data center impacts isn’t due until next July. Until then, there’s no statewide picture of how much water these facilities could draw from the aquifer we all share.


It might seem odd to worry about water supply just weeks after historic flooding (parts of the region saw what forecasters called a 1-in-1,000-year rain), but much of that rainfall ran through the canals and out to the lagoon. We don’t want to end up like the Ancient Mariner, with “Water, water, everywhere, nor any drop to drink.”

What the “Harm” Rollback Means for Manatees and the Lagoon

Manatee protection in the Indian River Lagoon just lost its strongest legal tool, and it all comes down to one word: “harm.”


The case

In 2022, Bear Warriors United sued the Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP). They argued that FDEP’s permits for septic systems and sewage plants let nitrogen and phosphorus flow into the northern lagoon. That pollution fed algae blooms, the blooms killed the seagrass, and manatees starved. The lawsuit came after a record 1,100 manatee deaths statewide in 2021, many of them from starvation.


The Endangered Species Act makes it illegal to “take” a protected animal, and “take” includes “harm.” Since 1981, federal rules had defined harm to include destroying habitat in a way that actually kills or injures wildlife, and the Supreme Court upheld that definition in 1995. In 2025 a federal judge sided with Bear Warriors and ordered FDEP to act. The order included pausing new septic permits in the northern lagoon.


What changed

In July 2026, the Trump administration removed that definition from the federal rules, effective September 14. Under the new reading, harm means only a deliberate act aimed directly at an animal (closer to shooting or trapping). On October 8, the appeals court threw out the judge’s ruling and order and sent the case back to be reconsidered. The lawsuit is still alive, but the septic pause and the other requirements are gone for now.


A few unexpected upsides

The rollback left a loose thread. The rules still ban “harassing” protected animals, including careless acts that seriously disrupt feeding, which could cover starving manatees (though the administration may try to remove that next). The change also leaves developers less legally certain: if courts restore the old reading, projects built without permits have no protection, so many are being advised to keep minimizing habitat damage anyway. And states are pushing back. California passed a law to cover any species that loses federal protection, and 20 states and D.C. have sued.


Why it’s a big deal

Pollution rarely kills manatees directly. It kills their food. Under the new reading, a chain like permits → pollution → algae → seagrass die-off → starvation doesn’t count, because nobody was aiming at a manatee. The problem goes well beyond our lagoon, since habitat loss is the leading threat to most endangered species. Manatees are still covered by the Marine Mammal Protection Act and Florida’s Manatee Sanctuary Act, but conservation lawyers say neither works as well as the ESA.


Why there’s still a fighting chance

In 2024 the Supreme Court ruled (in Loper Bright) that courts no longer have to defer to an agency’s reading of a law. The administration used that ruling to justify the rollback, but it cuts both ways. The judge now has to decide what the ESA itself means, not what the agency says it means. A legal memo prepared for CWC lays out how Bear Warriors can argue that Congress meant harm to include habitat destruction all along:

  • In the 1973 Senate record, the floor manager added “harm” specifically to fix language that had been dropped by mistake in committee.

  • The law already bans hunting, shooting, wounding and killing. If “harm” only meant direct attacks, the word would add nothing.

  • Since 1982, getting a permit for accidental “take” has required a habitat conservation plan. That requirement only makes sense if habitat was covered.

  • The ESA’s stated purpose is to conserve the ecosystems endangered species depend on.


What can fix it

  1. Winning the case on remand. Whoever loses will likely appeal, and other courts are deciding the same question. This could end up at the Supreme Court, which would take years.

  2. Lawsuits against the rollback itself. At least four suits were filed in July (by environmental groups and a tribe) asking courts to strike down the new rule and restore the old definition. This could be the fastest route.

  3. A new administration. One taking office in January 2029 could restore the definition by rule. That wouldn’t settle things for good, though. Courts now decide the law’s meaning for themselves, and a later administration could flip it again.

  4. Congress. Writing habitat protection into the ESA itself is the only lasting fix. Save the Manatee Club is backing two pending bills, the SAFE for Manatees Act (H.R. 9590) and the Protect Gulf Life Act (H.R. 8919), but quick action is unlikely.

  5. Local work. Seagrass comes back when nitrogen goes down, whatever the legal definition says. Septic-to-sewer conversions, stormwater upgrades and fertilizer rules are still the most direct way to help manatees, and they’re within our reach now.


Waiting until 2028 is one option, but it’s neither the fastest nor the most lasting. The court fights could restore protections sooner, and cleaning up the water helps manatees no matter how the courts rule.

2026 Mid-Term General Election Results & Prospects

About 65% of all Indian River County registered voters participated in the November 3rd Mid-Term General Election. The following candidates were elected or reelected for local offices:

  • Darren Soto (D) – U.S. Representative – District 9

  • Robert Brackett (R) – Florida Representative - District 34

Indian River County Commission:

  • Jennifer Pippin (R) – District 2

  • Deryl Loar (R) – District 4


Vero Beach City Council:

  • Linda Moore

  • Aaron Vos

  • Tracey Zudans


Sebastian City Council:

  • Sherrie Matthews

  • Deborah Shellenberger  


Funding from local, state, and federal governments remains needed to advance efforts to restore the Indian River Lagoon and Blue Cypress Lake. A prime example of this need surrounds the State mandate that the County convert septic-to-sewer infrastructure by 2030; funding has not yet been budgeted or provided to meet this mandate.   


Passage of Amendment 3 – for the “Increased Homestead Exemption” – will significantly reduce local government revenue based on taxable property values. Governor DeSantis has proposed to convene a Special Session of the Florida Legislature – before January - to implement the Amendment including measures to prevent local governments from replacing property tax revenue with new fees or taxes. Due to uncertainty how the Legislature will implement Amendment 3, Indian River County is challenged to identify:

  • which portions of the County’s budget will require cuts, and 

  • what alternative revenue sources may become available. 


Local funding is key to restoration of the Lagoon - as demonstrated by Brevard County. In 2016, Brevard County voters approved a half-cent sales tax to fund the Save Our Indian River Lagoon Project Plan. As part of the November 3, 2026 General Election, over 70% of Brevard County voters approved a 10-year renewal of the ½ cent sales tax to continue to provide local funds to restore and protect the Lagoon. Justification of voter approval was supported by County water quality monitoring that demonstrates the effectiveness of Plan projects completed with substantial funding from state and federal grant programs.  The Plan is projected to raise $586,000,000 over 10 years allowing Brevard County to continue to provide local funds to match funding from state and federal grant programs.


To restore the Indian River Lagoon and Blue Cypress Lake, our elected government officials must proactively support local, state and federal appropriations to provide needed funds. As exemplified by Brevard County, the prospects for Lagoon restoration within Indian River County will depend upon local government funding.

Septic to Sewer Update


Septic to sewer conversions are moving forward, and here’s where CWC’s three projects stand.


IRLNEP 1 (Water Quality): This $199,500 grant from the Indian River Lagoon National Estuary Program is now complete. We connected 47 homes to sewer, well past the grant’s requirement of 35.


Pilot Program: 44 connections are completed or in process, and we expect to finish with about 49. Grant amount: $240,000.


IRLNEP 2 (Priority Areas): The $255,000 grant will fund up to 50 connections.


That’s 91 homes connected or on the way, with 50 more to come. This takes a real partnership, so a big thank you to the Indian River Land Trust and the Indian River Community Foundation, who were with us from the start; One Lagoon/IRLNEP for its grant funding; the Economic Opportunities Council for handling applications and eligibility; and the City of Vero Beach for free financing, connection fee credits, and keeping the systems running. Thank you most of all to every homeowner who signed on. Each home taken off septic means cleaner water for the lagoon.


One thing to check: the October 2025 press release says IRLNEP’s June 2025 grant was $255K, but your note lists $255,000 for IRLNEP 2, which is just starting, and $199,500 for IRLNEP 1. Your current figures are probably right, but make sure the amounts are attached to the right grants.


 
 
 

Comments


Clean Water Coalition
of Indian River County, Inc.
​

P.O. Box 2171
Vero Beach, FL 32961

​

772-272-8080

​

Email: info@cwcirc.org

© Clean Water Coalition of Indian River County. The CWC is a 501(c)(3) non-profit organization. Click here to read our privacy policy.

bottom of page